Wednesday, November 08, 2006

Religious Liberty, Part II

The Bible teaches that there is absolute truth. Truth comes from God and His mind. Jesus is the embodiment of that truth as the second person of the Trinity in incarnate form. Jesus is the divine Logos who is truth, reason, order and the communication of God Himself. Jesus did not use armed force to spread the Gospel. Instead, God has chosen to spread the good news about Jesus Christ through preaching rather than the power of the sword. Christians have sometimes been mistaken in attempting to use means other than persuasion to spread religious truth. But the biblical text itself clearly supports the notion that the good news of Jesus Christ is to be spread through preaching and persuasion rather than through force or intimidation. Likewise, it rejects bribery and economic pressure as a means for spreading the Gospel. While it took hundreds of years for European Christians to put this notion into action, the fact is that the doctrine was always present in the Scripture itself. It took time for the idea to work itself out into the consciousness of the society.

The same thing is true of conscience. Romans chapter 2 tells us that God has written His law on the heart of all human beings, both Jews and Gentiles. When Luther said it was neither right nor safe to go against conscience, he was thinking of a God-given conscience—the God-given conscience of a Christian in particular—rather than a mere social construction. If conscience were purely a social construct, it would not make sense to say that you will go with a social construct against the authority of the very society that is responsible for constructing the conscience. Luther’s stand and the idea of freedom of conscience assume that conscience ultimately comes from a source other than social power and pressure. While social norms may mend or mar our higher conscience and make us feel guilty or pleased about actions that are actually evil or truly good, our deep conscience, the moral knowledge that we have from being created in the image of God and illumined by the divine light of God’s general revelation exalt human beings morally accountable before God and means that all human beings have at least some native ability to understand God’s demands even though outside of Christ they do not have the power to comply to any serious degree with those demands. We respect conscience because of its biblical source and because of the need of all people to be free to worship God. One of the Ten Commandments indicates that everyone should be able to observe the Sabbath. Not only are free people given the Sabbath off, but animals, prisoners of war and debtors or prisoners working off their debts are to be allowed to rest on the Sabbath. In describing this rule for the Sabbath, God is indicating that all creatures should be given the opportunity to give what they owe to God. All of us should be able to give proper worship to God and to give Him proper place in our lives. Even if we are bound by other commitments or relationships, those commitments or relationships cannot supersede what is owed to God Himself. Hence we allow people freedom of conscience to give what they believe what they owe to God.

We have found through bitter experience that the government is a poor arbiter of religious duty. As a result, we have found that it is best to leave people free to pursue the dictates of their conscience provided that they do not undertake things that are clearly against the moral law of God such as murdering innocent people in order to fulfill that perceived or actual duty.

Individual rights also find their foundation in the Bible. The Scripture clearly talks about moral obligations both of individuals, nations and governments that transcend human authority, governmental sovereignty or social consensus. Indeed, the whole point of many of the illustrations of Scripture is the importance of one man or woman or a group of men or women standing firm against the clear dictates of government, society and false religions. Moral dictates create reciprocal rights. The prohibition of murder creates a right to life. The existence of moral commands creates a right to fulfill those moral commands. The command not to steal creates a right to private property. While a right to life can be forfeited by capital crime or a right to property cannot extend to misuse property over which we have stewardship because stewardship in property is entrusted to us by the God who owns the universe and everything in it, these rights are predispositions of justice rather than immutable entitlements. The existence of individual rights is clearly indicated by the tone, tenor and attitude of Scripture even though there is no explicit discussion of rights as such. Once again, this was not something that occurred to westerners immediately upon conversion to Christianity. Rather, it was something that worked its way out as they absorbed the Christian worldview and began to struggle with the problem of applying Scripture to their lives. Today we sometimes take individual rights too far by believing that we can have individual rights to do things that are evil. While we can have rights that make it easier to get away with doing things that are bad, there can never be any right to do something wrong. God only gives us rights to choose among goods and rights to be free to do what is good. Evil must be tolerated that freedom may exist, but no one ever has a right to do something evil in itself. Hence there cannot be an individual right to abortion or a right to murder one’s spouse or a right to abuse one’s children. Rights are also evident from the nature and order of God’s creation. The rights of human beings are in part related to the kind of thing a human being is and the duties entrusted to human beings by God. Since God is the ultimate owner of all things including human beings, and since human beings have no right to own one another, a variety of realities about individual rights flow from these facts. But rights are a huge topic and we could go on about them forever, so back to these three foundational principles of religious liberty.

Tuesday, November 07, 2006

Democrates Against Democracy

Now that we are once again in an election season, there is more talk once again this year about election fraud and the supposed repression of voters. Throughout American history there have been instances of voter fraud, especially in New York City, New Jersey and a few of the northeastern states. Chicago is also known for its own problems in this respect. While there has been Republican involvement in election fraud, the majority of well-known historical election fraud has been perpetrated by the Democratic Party. The same is still true today. When illegal aliens and dead people vote, they are usually voting Democrat, although the recent scandal in Orange County has shown that Republicans are not free from fault in this respect. History has shown that there was substantial election fraud in the election between John F. Kennedy and Richard Nixon. Kennedy won because of fraudulent election results. Nixon was aware of this but waived his right to object and demand an investigation. Nixon believed that the integrity of American’s belief in voting and democracy was more important than the results of his individual race.

Today we experience exactly the opposite. Even though there is relatively little voter fraud and virtually no voter intimidation, left wing elements within the Democratic Party are constantly trying to create the impression that there is wide-spread intimidation of Democrat voters and that there is wide-spread voter fraud by Republicans. Neither of these things is empirically true. If anything, the reverse is probably the case. Nevertheless, this constant rebel rousing about voter intimidation and fraud is creating growing doubt among the American electorate.

Democracy requires trust in order to function. People have to believe that their votes really count. They have to believe that voting is a viable substitute for forced violence and the rule of the mob. By reducing trust in our election system, these radical elements within the Democratic Party are undermining democracy itself in the United States. Perhaps this is logical for them since many radical left-wing elements believe in one form of totalitarian rule or another. But for those many people in the Democrat and Republican parties who love freedom, raising the level of distrust in democracy is neither rational nor wise. Even though the electorate may not always make the right decision, it is better for us to have a republic in which people vote than to be under the control of elites or to have public offices swayed by who can put forward the most persuasive (or the best news media covered) demonstration in major cities.

Monday, November 06, 2006

Moral Failure of Christian Leaders

In the news once again this season, we have articles about a major Christian leader who is accused of moral failings. Sadly, this is all too common but not surprising. Some people like to point out the moral failings of Christian leaders as an attack against the truth of Christianity. But Christianity does not predict that its leaders or its rank and file believers will be free from immorality or hypocrisy. Christianity as a system predicts precisely the opposite: it says that all human beings commit sins. After we become Christians, our sins are forgiven and God works within us to gradually make us better and better people. But in this life we do not obtain apparent perfection. In fact, God often calls to Himself the very people who have the greatest problems with sin and temptation. So even though Christians may be improving throughout their lives, they are frequently people who struggle more with sin and character than the “good people” of the world who, though they sin, may sin less or have character defects which are less evident. God in His mercy and kindness often chooses the weak among us rather than the strong.

I think it is also the case that many people are led into the Christian ministry of pastorship, teaching or counseling in part because of their own struggles with sin and self. God also calls those with problems to help and encourage others with problems. Because of these facts, it is not surprising when any Christian, let alone a Christian minister, fails to live up to the standards to which we are called. It is also the case that Christian ministers are often under greater spiritual attack and pressure. The temptations presented to them are often more egregious than those facing people with less responsibility. But for the grace of God protecting us from temptation that we are unable to bear, any person would succumb to life-destroying temptations given the right circumstances.

It is true nevertheless that the Bible clearly articulates that those with leadership and authority among the people of God should be relatively pure in their outer moral actions and relatively strong in character. As a result, when allegations of serious sexual misconduct or fraud or crime turn out to be true, it is sometimes necessary to temporarily, or in some cases even permanently, remove a person from leadership within the church. But we must do so with humility since any of us could easily fall into the same situation. Christians are broken people accepting the gifts that God offers to us. As C.S. Lewis has said, whenever we do anything right, God is deserving of the credit. Whenever we do anything wrong, that is the result of our own selves.

Because of the truths I am describing in this article, people within the world have no real right to criticize Christianity because of the moral failings of our leaders. As I say, their failings are merely verifying Scripture’s understanding of human nature. In addition, people within the church should not let these events discourage them. Instead we should re-double our efforts to allow God to sanctify us through the transforming power of His Word. We should re-double our efforts to pray for our leaders and ourselves that we will not be led into temptation and that God will deliver us from evil. And as the church takes the actions it must, we should look upon our fallen heroes with an attitude of humility, love and mercy. And, we should try to undertake such safeguards as we can to avoid temptation in our own lives and to protect other leaders from falling into temptation. Financial audits, office doors with windows, computer internet filters, and accountability to spouses and to friends can seem like unnecessary irritations, but they are really wise safeguards to help all of us avoid the problems to which our human nature makes us susceptible even after our conversion to Christ. As I have grown older, as I have read the books of more Christian authors, and as I have come to know more great Christian men and women, I have come to realize that maturity in Christ, rather than resulting in moral perfection, leads us more and more to a consciousness of our sinfulness and vulnerability. Even those among us who we account strong and mature are in need of sanctification, study, and fellowship. Human laws also have a role. Good human laws help us avoid the worse sins than we already find present in our hearts and minds.

May God have mercy upon us all and hasten His sanctification process within His people. May we all do what we can to avoid temptation and to pray that the Lord will cause us to allow Him to grow the fruit of His Spirit in our lives. The Scriptures say that the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control; against such, there is no law.

Friday, November 03, 2006

Three Foundations of Religious Liberty

On October 13th and 14th, international lecturer, Vishal Mangalwadi, spoke at the speaker series we have here at Trinity. Dr. Mangalwadi talked about many things related to religious persecution, the situation in India and historical matters, but one interesting portion of his speech was about religious liberty. Dr. Mangalwadi noted that in the West religious liberty has largely developed based upon three ideas: truth, conscience and constitutionalism to protect individual rights.

Traditionally, the West has believed that objective truth exists and will triumph in a free discussion of ideas. Milton wrote about this during the time of the great English civil war of the 17th century. The great Huguenot jurist, Mornay, also spoke about this on his diplomatic journeys to the Netherlands from France. While the West has religious wars for a period of time, it was ultimately the consensus of western peoples that truth should be a matter of persuasion rather than a matter of violence.

Freedom of conscience has been a foundational principle of religious liberty in the West. The need to follow conscience was exemplified by Martin Luther who indicated at the Diet of Worms that he was unwilling to bow to the claims of human authority, but rather must follow his conscience unless convinced that his conscience was incorrect by reasoned argument from the Scripture. Likewise, the Westminster Confession emphasizes the need for freedom of conscience. This is not to say that there are not things that are right or wrong or true of false. The deep conscience is given to us by God, and contains genuine moral information. While our higher consciences may be affected by society, upbringing, and ill treatment or false belief, our deep consciences flow from God’s nature and God’s image imprinted on man through the divine light. Though that image is damaged by sin, we still must respect the genuine dictates of real conscience. We have faith that the power of conscience should not be made subservient to the power of government without some sort of reasoned persuasion from the Word of God as to the proper content of conscience.

Mangalwadi spoke last of the foundation of belief in individual rights. Again, the Huguenots had a fundamental role in the early development of constitutionalism and the belief that constitutions should protect and reserve the rights of the people against their governments. Samuel Rutherford and John Locke, influenced by the writings of the Huguenots, expounded these concepts for the English speaking peoples. The notion of rights is also a fundamental part of the development of the English common law with its emphasis on the proper predisposition of justice toward the preservation of life, property, and the freedom to choose among goods necessary to develop virtue and achieve what relative human happiness is possible in a fallen world.

All three of these foundations, truth, conscience and individual rights, were developed in the West because of the Bible and its influence. Mangalwadi is currently developing a video series that will discuss the role of the Bible in western civilization. I believe he is correct in asserting the role of biblical truth in supporting the development of the foundational ideas which in turn support religious freedom. In the next post of this series, I will argue that the Bible is the origin of the three foundations of religious liberty.

Thursday, November 02, 2006

When the Right is Wrong; the Power of the Courts and Natural Law

The Supreme Court is an institution with an interesting history. It has almost always been controversial. Sometimes it has been right, and sometimes it has been wrong. In the early history of the United States, the Court wrote an opinion upholding the rights of Cherokee Indians against the United States government. The Court was right at that point. Andrew Jackson, however, refused to implement the Court’s decision. Jackson was wrong about the Indians but he was partially right about constitutional checks and balances: he had the power to interpret the Constitution and laws in good faith and could refuse to abide by the Court’s ruling except in the specific instance decided by the Court. Abraham Lincoln followed the same principle following Dred Scott. The Court was wrong in the Dred Scott opinion. They decided that black people could not have the rights of regular American citizens. Lincoln could do nothing to help Dred Scott, but he disagreed with the Court’s opinion and refused to put it into practice. Lincoln continued to issue passports and do other executive branch acts that treated black people as citizens of the United States with equal rights. During the 1800’s the Court was seen as an important applier of constitutional meaning in individual cases but not as an ultimate arbitrator of constitutional meaning in all cases.

Opinion about the Court’s power shifted in the 1900s. In the first half of the century various versions of positivism became dominant. Positivists said law was not a “brooding omnipresence in the sky” (to quote Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.). The positivists thought that law was not based on natural law and reason, but was whatever the legislatures and courts said it was. Positivists saw law as a science of articulated power. To the degree that law was within the jurisdiction of the courts, positivists saw law as whatever judges said or did. With respect to the common law this made some sense. But with respect to the Constitution, this was a revolutionary idea. Courts in the past had thought of the Constitution as a higher law that was founded upon, and clarified, the implications of the still higher natural law that gave power to the Declaration of Independence, the acts of the people, and the Constitutional Convention. If a constitution was seen merely as a document that provided a jumping off point for the articulation of evolving judicial opinion, this was something entirely different.

The Court earned its new power by doing something right. During the 1950s, legislatures in the separate states and the federal government were unwilling to make necessary progress in putting into action the implications of the amendments passed after the Civil War. Clearly black people were entitled to equal treatment and equal civil rights. But the legislatures did not take action to vouchsafe those civil rights. In the 1950s, the courts began to move to protect genuine civil rights. In doing so, they stretched their powers. The courts normally did not have the authority to oversee ongoing activities of executive branch entities in detail. They normally did not have the power to set government policy. But because of the positivism and legal realism of the earlier part of the 1900s, and because the Court was doing something right in standing up for civil rights, no one was willing or able to question the Court’s reach for power. The Court did a good thing, but in doing so they developed powers that stretched beyond the original design of the Constitution. As a result of the civil rights cases, the high court of the United States claimed the ability to be the ultimate arbitrator of the meaning of the U.S. Constitution. Because of this power, in practice, and because of the legal positivism and legal realism taught by American law schools, American politicians and lawyers came to accept that the Supreme Court really was not only the ultimate arbitrator of the Constitution, but in a sense, the font of a living Constitution that was comprised of whatever the Court said. Based on this new view of their power, the high court enacted and created new “rights” that were antithetical to the original constitutional order and to natural law: the right to abortion being chief among them. Both then and now there were some dissenters on the Court, but the dissenters’ opinions were not always as helpful as they might be.

Just today I saw on the internet some comments by Justice Scalia (who is a brilliant, and who is right about the law most of the time) in which he was essentially talking about the Court as a guardian of democracy. Scalia sees his role as doing whatever the majority of citizens in the country want him to do as expressed through their legislators. Scalia admits that he is personally opposed to abortion and that there is no right to abortion in the Constitution as it is currently written. But Scalia also admits that if the majority of the people would vote for a constitutional amendment, through the proper process, guaranteeing the right to abortion, then he would be happy to uphold that new right. Scalia apparently takes a Hobbesian positivist view of the law. He seems to be saying that whatever the majority wants, the majority gets, whether it is genuinely right or wrong. This is a problem. Suppose the majority of people passed a constitutional amendment denying civil rights to people based upon race or national origin? That would be immoral, clearly wrong and clearly contrary to the text of other provisions in the Constitution. Would the Court then uphold this provision merely because it had been passed by the majority of people through the proper process? Would they forget to make any objection even in principle?

Human beings have a right to life because they are human beings. That right comes from God and is inalienable. It is recognized in the Declaration of Independence, a foundational document of our government. The right to life cannot be taken away or disparaged by statute or even by constitutional amendment because it is based in a higher law than that of the Constitution. The problem is that today our society no longer understands, embraces or correctly articulates the higher law. We have so deluded ourselves in our claim that no such law exists that we have begun to pretend we forget what it actually says. Deep down it is undoubtedly true that the law is still there, but we have suppressed its meaning just as the southerners suppressed it when they insisted on making black people their slaves. We have suppressed the moral truth that human beings are human in all stages of development and that human beings are entitled to enough of a right to life that they cannot be intentionally killed with malice aforethought and without justification or excuse. We have allowed their intentional killing provided that they are very small and out of sight because they are in woman’s womb or in a petri dish. Justice Scalia’s rejection of the Court’s claim to be the font of revised constitutional text is justifiable and correct. But his belief in pure democracy as an antidote is simply suggesting a weaker poison in exchange for stronger.

Wednesday, November 01, 2006

Why You Should Vote

At the link is my post of October, whith comments, on why Republicans need to get out and support Republican candidates even if they are not completely happy with the party record. The main reason: government by the Democrates will be much worse. Even if the Democrate candidate in your race is pro-life, he will vote for a leadership that will ruthlessly fight for abortion in judicial nominations and statutes. Why go from people who are ineffective in getting what you want to peple who will deliberatly do the opposite of what you want.

Legal Ethical Dilemmas III - Anger

Another common legal dilemma is the use of anger. A fellow Christian once told me that anger is a gift given to us by God in order to deal with evil. Anger is an appropriate reaction against evil. The Bible clearly allows this to be true. Jesus was angry when He threw the moneychangers out of temple. But the Bible also says that we need to have limits to our anger. We are “not to let the sun go down on our wrath.” If you perpetuate your anger and are angry all the time, or if you internalize your anger and refuse to give it acknowledgement or expression, the ends are the gradual destruction of mind and body. While anger is good at the appropriate times and in the appropriate amounts, it is corrosive and can be destructive in the wrong amounts or at the wrong time. There is a danger in the law of turning the law into a milk toast occupation in which righteous indignation has no role. But that danger is not the most common in our society.

Today we live in a world that is more and more politicized. People involved with plaintiff’s personal injury work often believe that industry is populated by vicious, cold-blooded robber barons who are eager to give the masses cancer, disease and destruction in order to make a quick buck. Conversely, lawyers involved in the insurance defense business are sometimes equally partisan. They often believe that the plaintiff’s bar is full of men and women who are encouraging fraudulent and frivolous litigation in order to make money at the expense of the economy and legitimate business practices. The plaintiff’s bar thinks that people are reckless with other people’s lives and health. The defense bar believes that the plaintiff’s bar is making demands that cannot be met in a fallen world. The defense attorney says life cannot be perfect and human life cannot be risk free. In order to live and have agriculture, industry and other means of feeding and clothing people, we have to undertake activities that have risks. And if society were to fully internalize all the economic externalities of those risks, we might easily restore ourselves to the quality of life present in the early Middle Ages rather than to the environmental paradise sought by the plaintiff’s bar. Each side has their argument and their perspective. More and more often attorney’s tempers grow short.

It is common among legal practitioners that they not only believe the other side’s tactics are malicious attempts to waste time and increase the costs of litigation rather than efforts at gathering genuine evidence to encourage settlement or prepare for trial. As tempers escalate, threats of sanctions and demands for additional rules and statutes designed to punish parties for asking too many questions or filing illegitimate claims grow greater and greater. There is a time for anger in practice—when faced with genuine and clearly identifiable evil. But most anger in practice today is counterproductive. Most lawyers are reasonable people. Though they are sinners, like all humanity, they are trying to do the best they can do for their clients. It is not their desire to impoverish society or to eliminate justice. While there are always some attorneys who are crooked, they are still, thankfully, not the majority of attorneys. Frequently a lot of the anger and bitterness in litigation comes about through misunderstanding. Lawyers have differences of opinion about the proper scope of discovery or the results that they think their discovery should achieve. When the other side resists answering questions that they believe are beyond the proper scope of discovery, or when they do not produce the documents or evidence that their opponents conjecture to exist, the result is not only anger but escalating threats and threatening court filings. Each side assumes the other side is being willful and malicious. I have found that it is far more productive to assume that the other attorney is simply trying to do his job. If one deals with an angry fellow attorney with kindness and concern rather than attempting to escalate anger and threats, the result is usually that opposing counsel relaxes and a productive dialogue can begin. It is odd in our society that we are so willing to be pacifists in international affairs, and claim that if people would all just decide that war is never the solution to problems, that everybody would agree and we would have universal peace. But in our private business and legal transactions where a genuine peace is far more possible than in international affairs, we refuse to agree that matters could be settled by reason and discussion, and insist on litigation as war.

When attorneys agree to talk with one another and to treat the litigation process as a rational exchange of reasoned views and material evidence, the process is more effective and easier on both of the parties and the attorneys. The stress and anger that comes from the assumption of sharp practice and retaliation is not worth what it produces.

It is true that clients frequently encourage litigation as war. The clients want their attorneys to be zealous and they believe that a gentle discussion between counsel may mean that they are being sold out for the sake of the ”good old boy network.” As a result, some attorneys engage in theatrics in order to appease their clients. But the proper role of an attorney is to be a counselor who persuades his client to do what is right, not to be a mercenary who engages in bloodletting for his client’s entertainment. Attorneys are the first line of defense against genuinely malicious clients. It is never in a client’s best interest to act maliciously or destructively. Skilled attorneys must always be at work to convince their clients to do what is right because doing what is right is what is really in your client’s best interest. Wrongs will eventually be discovered, if not by the trial court, perhaps by the heavenly court. Wrong does eventually out, and our job as attorneys is not to enable our clients wrong, but to counsel our clients to do what is right. Many lawyers are afraid to do this because they believe that counseling their clients in the right will lose them business. They prefer telling their clients whatever they want to hear and then happily billing the money necessary to pick up the pieces after their client’s will results in an explosion of litigation and accusation. But this is wrong. I have found that in reality when clients are counseled to do what is right and kept away from those gray areas that tempt their customers and fellow businessmen to litigation, the client is not only happy, but grateful. If people find out that you are an honest attorney who will tell them the truth and encourage them in the right way, you may lose a few angry clients but the general public will beat a path to your door. In addition, you will be a much happier attorney and live a longer and happier life. You will also contribute to a happier community and a happier world. While your belief that litigation need not be war will not end all wars, it may contribute to social stability and a community feeling. And if we love our neighbors as ourselves, isn’t that the sort of thing we should want for our neighbors?

Tuesday, October 31, 2006

Happy Reformation Day

Nearly 500 years ago, in 1517, Martin Luther nailed his 95 Theses for proposed debate to the door of the Castle Church in the German University town of Wittenberg. There were reformers before and after Luther, but the anniversary of the posting is the day chosen for Reformation Day - a day to celebrate the breaking out of Biblical truth that transformed Europe and returned much of Christendom to a Biblical view of salvation.

The Reformation is based on a handful of simple but profound ideas. First, the Bible is the ultimate standard for God's revealed truth, not church tradition or hierarchical authority. Second, we are saved by faith in Jesus, including transforming belief in the propositional truths of who Jesus is and what Jesus did for us. And third, this salvation through faith is by God's grace to us alone, not because of any merit or attribute we posses.

Amidst the darkness of the way the world celebrates October 31, remember the light of the gospel.

New Jersey Decision: Lewis v. Harris

On October 25, 2006, the New Jersey Supreme Court released an opinion in which they require the New Jersey legislature to create a scheme for same sex couples to marry. The summary of the opinion identifies the main reason for the opinion: “Denying committed same sex couples the financial and social benefits and privileges given to their married heterosexual counterparts bears no substantial relationship to a legitimate government purpose.” The New Jersey court erroneously believes that marriage is basically a contractual device aimed at “financial and social benefits.” This is part of an erroneous view of marriage. Marriage is not merely a contract, it is a covenant relationship ordained by God for special purposes. The terms of marriage can be violated but marriage cannot be broken like a contract whose force disappears when one of the parties fails to abide by the terms of the contract. Otherwise marriages would last about fifteen minutes: until the bridegroom notices a bridesmaid’s cleavage or the bride refuses to obey a casual request of the groom.

The New Jersey case is also noteworthy because the side allegedly defending marriage sandbagged itself by failing to argue (at least the high court of New Jersey said they failed to argue) that marriage exists as an institution to “encourage procreation or to create the optimal living environment for children.” Other states have upheld traditional marriage precisely on that basis. The NJ court rejects it nevertheless. Radically political liberal courts cannot see marriage as a God-ordained institution or the law as bordered by a higher divine law, they cannot justify denying financial benefits to people who want them, even if the status upon which they base their desire for those benefits is rooted in something contrary to the natural law. What will be next? Protection for the sacred rights of safecrackers to carry out their profession unabated by the police? Rights of communalists to mixed group marriage? The right of women to eliminate bothersome ex-husbands by execution? Or the need to preserve the traditional right of used car salesmen to defraud their customers? What other immoral economic and social benefits can be justified by positive law?

Friday, October 27, 2006

Blog Conference

Since Thursday afternoon I have been attending Biola Universities' Godblogcon conference. I have had the pleasure to meet and talk to many great bloggers. I have linked to most of them over on the bottom of the blog roll at the right. Special thanks to Think Christian for mentioning my site. There have been good posts about the conference on Think Christian, The Susan Blog, and Skye Puppy among others.

Thursday, October 26, 2006

Europe surrenders and Demands We Do the Same

On similar lines to the fjordman article bellow, the article at the link above (hat tip: Rantburg) discuses how Europeans loss of their Christian faith is causing Europe to abandon itself to Islam. Paul Belien writes that German author Hernryk M. Broder is encouraging young Europeans to leave Europe rather than loose their freedom. But the article points out that Europeans are unwilling to raise their birthrates or to risk death in war fighting for freedom. Instead they only want to enjoy freedom. And why?

“As Tom Bethell wrote in this month’s American Spectator: “Just at the most basic level of demography the secular-humanist option is not working.” But there is more to it than the fact that non-religious people tend not to have as many children as religious people, because many of them prefer to “enjoy” freedom rather than renounce it for the sake of children. Secularists, it seems to me, are also less keen on fighting. Since they do not believe in an afterlife, this life is the only thing they have to lose. Hence they will rather accept submission than fight. Like the German feminist Broder referred to, they prefer to be raped than to resist.
“If faith collapses, civilization goes with it,” says Bethell. That is the real cause of the closing of civilization in Europe. Islamization is simply the consequence. The very word Islam means “submission” and the secularists have submitted already. Many Europeans have already become Muslims, though they do not realize it or do not want to admit it.”

But to make matters worse, they try to stop others from defending truth and liberty too:

“People who are not prepared to resist and are eager to submit, hate others who do not want to submit and are prepared to fight. They hate them because they are afraid that the latter will endanger their lives as well. In their view everyone must submit.
This is why they have come to hate Israel and America so much . . .”

Europe's Hatred of its Foundation

At the link (hat tip: Rantburg) is an article by a writer with the pen name Fjordman on the importance of Christianity to Western Civilization and the multiculturalists suicidal embrace of Islam and hatred for Christianity. What makes the article unusual is that Fjordman is a non-believer. But he agrees with one quoted author that:

“As long as there is separation between religion and state, those of us who don't have any religious belief should prefer religions which tend to create reasonable and prosperous communities. Our traditional Judeo-Christian religions have proven this capability. Islam never has, and probably never will. As Australia's Cardinal George Pell says, ‘some seculars are so deeply anti-Christian, that anyone opposed to Christianity is seen as their ally. That could be one of the most spectacularly disastrous miscalculations in history.’”

Fjordman admits the hostility of current elites in Europe (and we might add parts of coastal America) to both Christianity and Judaism:

“The First Commandment of Multiculturalism is: Thou shalt hate Christianity and Judaism. Multiculturalists also hate nation states, and they even hate the Enlightenment, by insisting that non-Western cultures should be above scrutiny.
It is sometimes claimed that Islam is a "European" or Western religion. Ironically, we can test this by using "cosmopolitan Multiculturalists" such as Mr. Hylland Eriksen. They hate everything that's seen as Western and they like Islam, precisely because it's anti-Western.”
But as Fjordman also notes, Western civilization is what it is because of Christianity.

Tuesday, October 24, 2006

Legal Ethical Dilemmas II

The classic legal ethics dilemma everyone asks about is how a criminal defense attorney can represent someone they know to be guilty. The sort answer is a question “What makes you think you know they are guilty?” Real criminal clients do not usually admit they committed the crime – even to their own attorneys. And, indeed, if they do admit it how does the defense attorney know they are telling the truth and not either taking the fall for someone else or engaging in the habits of one of those mental instabilities that cause false confessions? The defense attorney does not know his client is guilty.

All too often in our society people assume that because the accused is a gang member or a rough character that they either committed the crime in question or some other crime, and so deserve to be convicted. But no one knows that except God and the accused. Our system, and real justice, convict or acquit people of specific crimes, not based on status. No one should be convicted because they are considered a member of a “criminal class.” Even a real professional criminal may not have committed the crime of which he is accused. This is especially true today because of the anonymity of big cities, the unreliability of personal identifications of strangers, and the reluctance of the police to use the expensive resources of finger printing and DNA evidence in cases of property crime.

But even if the client is guilty, there are reasons to feel good about defending them anyway.

First, the argument you have probably heard, our system of justice is an adversarial system. It depends for optimal outcomes on a prosecutor and a defense attorney each doing there best for their own side. The defense attorney is there to keep the prosecution honest and make sure no one is convicted without adequate evidence.

Second, a lawyer may seek mercy in place of justice. How do you know that God is not working in the life of defendant, and may not acquit him through the trial procedure for purposes of His own? If we all got what we deserve we would all be dead and damned. The defense lawyer may be an instrument of mercy just as the prosecution may be an instrument of justice.

Third, contrary to popular belief, most criminal defense work does not focus on “trying to get the client off.” In most cases the defense attorney reviews the evidence the prosecution will present, weighs the evidence, works to convince his client he is going to loose the case if a trail occurs, and negotiates a fair sentence in exchange for a guilty plea. Usually plea bargaining works. The plea agreements are often about right. You can have sentencing that is too heavy or too light, especially if you have judges who are social determinists, but usually my experience has been that plea bargaining produces just results.

And, contrary to the impression given by high profile trials with celebrity lawyers, trials usually (but not always) have reasonably just results. Real cases with guilty perpetrators do not usually result in acquittals based on technicalities or the exclusion of inadmissible evidence. And no one should be convicted on inadequate evidence no matter how strong the intuitions of a wronged society.

There is one real moral limitation in defending people accused of crimes however – no attorney should knowingly let his client take the stand and lie. If the client tries to lie the attorney must resign. But the client should be advised not to lie. Of course this brings us back to the first paragraph of this post though. The attorney does not usually know his client is guilty. So the attorney does not usually know if his client is lying or not. But then everyone is entitled to be given the benefit of the doubt by someone, if only by their attorney.

Monday, October 23, 2006

Why vote?

In an article at the link, Fred Barns is saying similar thinks to what I wrote last week. I agree with Barns.

I am hopeful the election is swinging back toward the Republicans keeping control of the House and Senate.